When to get which vaccine and how to get insurance to pay for it has some Americans ditching vaccines

Illustration by Molly Ferguson, Stat

If it's too hard to understand or to get done, many people will opt out -- as is the case with adults attempting to get vaccines.

"Alison Buttenheim was floored by a sign she saw in her doctor’s office when she went to get the first jab of the two-dose shingles vaccine to protect her against painful flare-ups of varicella zoster," reports Helen Braswell of Stat. "The notice read: 'Medicare patients cannot receive Tdap or zoster vaccines here. They need to obtain [them] at their pharmacy. If they receive it here, they need to pay out of pocket.' In this instance, patients could receive vaccines covered by Medicare as treatment, but not as a preventative measure. For instance, if a person stepped on a nail, Medicare would pay for their tetanus shot; however, if a patient is getting a tetanus booster to maintain protection, Medicare would not cover it.

Buttenheim, a professor of nursing at the University of Pennsylvania who studies vaccine acceptance and hesitancy, "knows that any amount of difficulty in the immunization process can deter people from getting vaccinated. She couldn’t believe her eyes," Branswell explains. "To stay abreast of what to get and when and where to get it almost requires would-be vaccine recipients to have advanced degrees. Buttenheim recently found herself shelling out $160 for her latest Covid booster. She told Branswell, "We’re absolutely making it too hard."

Branswell reports, "Some of that may be due to vaccine hesitancy but more of it is likely due to the sheer difficulty of knowing what to get, when to get it, and how to get insurance coverage for the various shots, said Saad Omer, a vaccine expert who is dean of the Peter O’Donnell Jr. School of Public Health at the University of Texas Southwestern." Omer told Branswell: “Beyond the cacophony of pro-vaccine and anti-vaccine arguments on X (formerly know as Twitter), most of the country doesn’t actively think about vaccines, period."