Emergency departments in some rural areas don't have 24/7 on-site physician coverage

A hospital in Ekalaka, Mont., sits at the intersection of two dirt roads. 
(Photo by Arielle Zionts, KFF Health News) 

Many rural emergency rooms are no longer run by attending physicians, but instead depend on care by nurse practitioners and physician assistants. "A recent study found that in 2022, at least 7.4% of emergency departments across the U.S. did not have an attending physician on-site 24/7," reports Arielle Zionts for KFF Health News. "More than 90% were in low-volume or critical access hospitals — a federal designation for small, rural hospitals."

The 2022 report represents "82% of hospitals that responded to a survey sent to all emergency departments in the country, except those operated by the federal government," Zionts writes. "The study is the first of its kind, so there isn’t proof that such staffing arrangements are increasing, said Carlos Camargo, the lead author and a professor of emergency medicine at Harvard Medical School."

The idea of an emergency department without a doctor on staff remains controversial, and not all states allow it. "Some doctors and their professional associations say physicians’ extensive training leads to better care, and that some hospitals are just trying to save money by not employing them," Zionts explains. Indiana, Virginia, and South Carolina have passed laws that require all their EDs to have a 24/7 physician on-site.

Even when states require their EDs to staff a round-the-clock doctor, that doesn't make finding one easy. "In the Dakotas, more than half of emergency departments were running without 24/7 attending physician staffing," Zionts reports. In response to the regional shortage, Sioux Falls-based Sanford Health launched an emergency medicine residency to help increase its ED physician numbers.

Some rural health advocates say lawmakers need to be sure that employing full-time ED physicians 24/7 is feasible for their region before passing legislation that requires it. Zionts adds, "Camargo said some doctors say that if lawmakers are going to require 24/7 on-site physician coverage in ERs, they need to pay to help hospitals implement it."