Opinion: Rural Americans rely on immigrant physicians for care, but new restrictions will leave them with fewer doctors

Rural hospitals have relied on foreign-born doctors
to provide care for decades. (MedPage Today photo)

Rural communities already struggle to staff their hospitals and clinics with physicians of all types, from specialists to family practitioners. The Trump administration's failure to make progress on immigration changes and the newly established $100,000 fee for each new H-1B visa application, which has no exemption for health care workers, will leave rural Americans with far fewer doctors to treat them, writes Manav Midha in his opinion for MedPage Today.

The difference in the number of physicians and the availability of specialists between urban and rural locations is stark. Midha writes, "There are approximately 263 specialists for every 100,000 people in urban areas compared to 30 for every 100,000 people in rural areas, and 46% of counties (and 86% of rural counties) have not a single cardiologist."

For decades, rural communities have relied on immigrant doctors for their care. Midha explains, "Foreign-born physicians are uniquely willing to serve rural communities even when few others move there. Immigration restrictions risk cutting off one of the last remaining lifelines for rural healthcare access."

Immigrant doctors who came to the U.S. in the 1980s and 1990s were able to obtain J-1 visas, which "allow for a path to permanent residency if a doctor works for at least 3 years in an area with underserved healthcare needs," Midha adds. They cared for patients in "rural Indiana, deep Appalachia, coastal Louisiana, and parts of Texas, hours from the closest city," where few American graduates wanted to live.

Congress could expand the Conrad 30 program to add some physicians with J-1 waivers who can treat in rural communities. "The bipartisan Conrad State 30 and Physician Access Reauthorization Act would have expanded (albeit slightly) the number of spots and extended the program. It was initially introduced in Congress in 2023 and again in 2025 but has seen little movement," Midha writes.

In the face of the current shortage, some states are developing their own approaches to help rural communities secure access to doctors. Midha writes, "At least 18 states, led by Tennessee, have enacted laws permitting internationally-trained physicians with appropriate experience to practice medicine without having to repeat medical residency."

Meanwhile, some rural communities may face a more severe shortage of physicians, and residents will have to travel longer distances for care. Expanding and developing paths for immigrant physicians "is not merely a moral imperative -- it is an economic one," Midha adds. "And it is one that can address one of the greatest challenges to equitable care."